Skip to content

Farm Journal

Organic-Ready From the Beginning Does Not Mean Certified Organic

RLF has a long-term interest in certified organic production. That statement needs an equally important sentence beside it: Whitcomb Regenerative Livestock Farm is not currently Certified Organic.

The difference matters because “organic” is not simply a description of good intentions. Certified Organic production is governed by specific standards, records, inspections, land history, feed and input requirements, livestock-health rules, traceability, and approved certification.

Our approach is to make future certification easier by preparing the recordkeeping system early instead of trying to reconstruct years of farm history after the fact.

That means documenting where feed and livestock come from, what inputs are used, how animals are identified, health treatments, grazing and land use, storage and handling, production records, and the history of fields that may eventually enter a certified operation. Once land is secured, the actual property history becomes especially important.

Keeping those records does not turn a product organic. It creates evidence that can support an Organic System Plan and certification application later.

We also intend to keep the certification goal in its proper place relative to animal welfare. An animal that medically needs treatment should receive appropriate treatment. If a particular treatment changes that animal’s eligibility for organic marketing, the record should preserve that distinction. Withholding necessary care to protect a label is not the kind of farm management we are trying to build.

The economics will matter too. Organic feed, certification fees, sourcing restrictions, paperwork, processing, and market premiums are different for different enterprises. The right question is not whether a certification badge sounds attractive. The question is whether certification improves the farm’s management, market position, and economics enough to justify its requirements for the specific enterprise.

In the meantime, we can still describe management accurately. Pasture-based, intensively managed grazing, regenerative goals, animal-welfare practices, and transparent sourcing can each be explained on their own terms without using a certification we do not yet hold.

The public claim rule is simple: plan toward organic where it makes sense, keep the records needed to prove what we do, and use the Certified Organic claim only after the responsible certifier says we have earned it.